Not Looking Away is the Foundation for Reconciliation

We cannot reconcile without facing our own darkness

I was sixteen years old when I saw a documentary on the Middle East that turned me upside down. I had just left the Jewish community of Amsterdam, and it was my first time mingling with gentiles. I had been accepted at an international boarding school, where the movie was shown.

Having grown up with only one version of the Middle East conflict—we bought the land from the Arabs, made it fertile, they got jealous and attacked us—I walked into the movie theater expecting the usual visuals of men and women with rolled-up sleeves planting fields or driving tractors. There were some familiar shots of dark-haired girls and boys dancing in a circle while holding hands, but soon a very different set of images appeared.

Rows and rows of people, many of them stooped over, with mournful eyes, walking on dusty roads in tattered clothes. Some of the women carried giant bales or metal pots on top of their heads; others held young infants. Old men in black-and-white checkered keffiyehs, leaning on their canes, knapsacks thrown over their shoulders. Barefoot young boys dragging younger siblings along. Everyone, without exception, exhausted and bereft.

Seeing those images, I was reminded of my mother and grandparents, and how they, too, had fled their beloved ancestral land, leaving everything behind. It was the first time I had heard about The Nakba, as Palestinians call it: The Catastrophe.

Their flight had been prompted by a massacre at a village called Deir Yassin. Over a hundred people were killed, the documentary said. More than fifty orphaned children were taken to the Jaffa Gate and dumped there. The film showed black-and-white photographs of little boys and girls with dark eyes too old for their age.

I watched the rest through blurry eyes. When the film ended, I could not move. The same words kept going round and round in my head: That's not possible.

Jews don't kill. We're the ones getting killed, not the ones doing the killing.

I could not yet conceive of Jews being good and bad, virtuous and cruel, oppressors and oppressed, like any other people.

Recently, the New York Times published an opinion column by Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist Nicholas Kristof, titled The Silence That Meets the Rape of Palestinians.

The piece caused a great uproar on social media, in headlines, and inside the American Jewish community.

The Israeli Foreign Ministry called it “one of the worst blood libels ever to appear in the modern press” and has announced it would sue the New York Times. None of what Kristof wrote was in fact new. He is a journalist who has spent decades documenting mass sexual violence, from Darfur to Congo, and all of it had already been reported in other outlets. But now that it is in more mainstream media, there is an eruption of fury and denialism.
None of what Kristof wrote was in fact new. He is a journalist who has spent decades documenting mass sexual violence, from Darfur to Congo, and all of it had already been reported in other outlets. But now that it is in more mainstream media, there is an eruption of fury and denialism.

Indeed, the details described in Kristof’s piece are too horrifying and gruesome to repeat here. My heart goes out to all victims of sexual violence—including the Israelis assaulted on October 7, and the Palestinians who, since that day, have lived under violent sexual assault or the threat of it, day after day.

I understand denialism. Facing one thing often means facing everything—it is truly the death of an old story and identity. It is not for nothing that Jung called facing our shadow the hardest thing humans can ever do.

There’s a brilliant interview with human rights lawyer Sari Bashi—executive director of the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel, an American-Israeli woman living in Ramallah with her Palestinian husband—about Kristof’s article and the reactions to it. In it, Sari says:

"The denial is understandable and if I'm being generous, maybe it even comes from a good place, it comes from not wanting to believe that human beings could do that to each other, and maybe not wanting to believe that in particular human beings who we associate as ours would do that to others."

This was exactly my default response as a sixteen-year-old.

Now, as a sixty-year-old, I know that going through that dark night of the soul—of facing the evil within—is part of the dismantling of an old identity that needs to die because it is not based in truth.

How can we reconcile if we cannot face our own darkness? What would there be to reconcile?

If instead we can acknowledge: yes, we were chased from our homes—and we have chased others from theirs. We have been made to suffer unspeakably—and we have caused others unspeakable suffering. We have been treated with terrible cruelty—and we, too, are capable of terrible cruelty.

That is how an honest dialogue becomes possible. That is how new pathways can emerge.
This is what the ancestors modeled, even from inside the Holocaust itself. As Bergen-Belsen survivor Abel Herzberg wrote:

“The Nazis were not inherently evil. They were ordinary human beings, conditioned over time and systematically molded into mass murderers. Given a certain set of circumstances and predispositions, the same thing could happen anywhere, to anyone.”

Anywhere. To anyone. Including us. Including now.

Reading Nicholas Kristof’s column brings me face to face with that truth.

Not looking away is the foundation of reconciliation.

Remember: your vision may not fit the world, because it was meant to remake it.

Niyati Evers

Want the wisdom the ancestors left us—and a way to use it?
Subscribe here to receive A Map for the Dark free—plus my weekly letters for our times